[speedgibson] Speed Gibson: American Idol - 7 Finalists

[Email subscription to blog articles]

Posted by Speed Gibson:
American Idol - 7 Finalists
http://speedgibson.powerblogs.com/posts/1208317199.shtml


   I don't think I've seen anything like this on American Idol. The
   judges went absolutely ape for David Cook's performance tonight. I
   didn't. David Cook is the one to beat, no question, but I sure
   question this as his best work to date. Great performances are solidly
   on key. David was not, unsteady throughout. I can't help but wonder if
   the judges were acting as producers keeping the star alive, as this
   song choice won't connect with Cook's fan base. Either way, he's safe.
   David Archuleta should be safe, too, though I didn't quite think he
   nailed it as much as the judges did. And I think Kristy Lee Cook might
   well be safe as well, given the strong finish.
   Jason Castro has simply leveled off. He's not bad, but he's not
   improving week to week. He's probably safe, too.
   The three remaining girls are my bottom three: Carly Smithson, Syesha
   Mercado, and Brooke White. Like Kristy, they all looked great. Carly
   even wore sleeves, and did as well as she could. I just don't think
   she has the vocal cords to deliver the challenging songs she picks.
   Brooke was having trouble singing and playing the piano.
   But sad for me, Syesha really disappointed this week. The song was a
   mess. Challenging, a good effort, but a mess. I think she's going home
   this week and it's a shame because she and David Archuleta are the
   only two that David Cook should worry about.