[speedgibson] Speed Gibson: American Idol - 8 Finalists

[Email subscription to blog articles]

Posted by Speed Gibson:
American Idol - 8 Finalists
http://speedgibson.powerblogs.com/posts/1207717191.shtml


   I didn't hear anything I would call great tonight. Or terrible, now
   that Ramiele Malubay is finaly gone. I give David Archuleta best in
   show, with the always underrated Syesha Mercado close behind.
   In the Randy Jackson "it was just OK for me" category were Michael
   Johns and Carly Smithson, even if she did bungle the last eight bars.
   David Cook came back to earth with a so-so offering. Jason Castro had
   the right idea. The ukelele was very effective but I heard more
   breathing than singing. Brooke White's "You've got a Friend" was messy
   and flat.
   I put Brooke White and Kristy Lee Cook at the bottom. I think Kristy
   should go. I found reasons to keep her before,
   number one being the presence of the Ramiele Malubay. But she's gone
   and Kristy should be next.