[donaldscrankshaw] Donald: The Immigration Debate

[Email subscription to blog articles]

Posted by Donald:
The Immigration Debate
http://www.donaldscrankshaw.com/posts/1181252359.shtml


   I've been staying out of the immigration debate. I've said some stuff
   on it before, mostly to the tune that the worker visa isn't really a
   bad idea, but it's tricky to implement. And having absorbed more of
   the debate before, it's obvious that the enforcement side is really,
   really tough, and we do a terrible job of it. In other words, I'm torn
   between the two sides without any substantial investment in either,
   which makes me just dead tired of the debate and the amazing level of
   venom involved. I really think that Jonah Goldberg gets it right in
   his [1]USA Today article:

     Conservatives normally take great pride in the caliber of our
     intramural debates. But this is a shameful moment.
     Oh, to be sure, there are racists, bigots, xenophobes and the like
     among the critics of immigration reform. Of this I am quite sure. I
     am also certain there are people who believe that the marketplace
     is the highest source of values, and the bottom line is the
     ultimate arbiter of right and wrong.
     ...
     But you know what? Even if these are the overriding motives for all
     of the combatants in the debate over immigration reform, none of
     them is publicly using these arguments to justify his position. No
     one â of any consequence at least â is saying we need to keep the
     Mexicans out because they're racially inferior. No one is openly
     pushing amnesty as a vital first step toward the nullification of
     the U.S. Constitution.
     Perhaps chief among the many problems with these sorts of
     accusations is that they help no one, advance nothing. Only those
     already convinced cheer the unsubstantiated charges of villainy.
     Indeed, crying racism to delegitimize an opponent's legitimate
     arguments is typically a left-wing tactic, and conservatives do not
     color themselves with glory by mimicking it.

   So can we please calm down and discuss this more rationally, and
   without the name-calling?

References

   1. http://blogs.usatoday.com/oped/2007/06/villiains_and_t.html